The infamous Madison Sq. Park hamburger "stand", the Shake Shack, reopens for business on March 21. To help you plan
your next 24 days, the Danny Meyer team has provided us with this handy Countdown Clock:
Now the real question -- how does Shake Shack compare to the other burgers available in New York City?
A quick regression: there are many things that New York does well in the world of food. Pizza for one. Haute cuisine
for another. There are some things that suck in New York: Mexican and BBQ (with R.U.B. being a decent exception) come
to mind.
So, back to the burger. New York happens to have a ton of spots that put out a great burger (if you don't believe
me, check out Chowhound for the debate).
My favorites, in order:
1) Molly's
2) Shake Shack
3) Paul's
4) McHale's (now closed)
5) Burger Joint
6) JG Melons
7) Cedar Tavern
There's definitely a few that I'm missing. I did notice a new "Burger Joint" at a bar called Scenic on Avenue B that
I want to check out. One place that did not make the list is New York Burger Co. (or something like that). While the
dipping sauces for the fries are great, the burger doesn't hold a candle to any place on the list above.
As soon as I figure out how to enable comments, all 3 of my readers can chime in as well.
Edit: Andrew has reminded me about Corner Bistro. I'd have to put that one probably between Burger Joint and JG
Melons on my list, although on atmosphere alone, it is great.